Active Listings
9
9 homes · $690K – $4.5M
West Bradenton
Explore Legends Bay
Gated. Golf. Waterfront. One of West Bradenton's most sought-after communities sitting just minutes from Sarasota Bay.
Legends Bay is a private gated community in West Bradenton offering a rare combination of golf course living, waterfront access, and modern construction. Homes here were built primarily between 2008 and 2026, giving buyers newer construction quality at a range of price points. The community sits adjacent to Sarasota Bay with a private marina, making it one of the few neighborhoods in the area where you can have a golf course lot, a pool, and boat access under one address.
- Gated community with private marina and bay access
- Golf course lots with resort-style amenities
- Newer construction — majority of homes built 2014–2026
- Minutes from IMG Academy, SRQ Airport, and downtown Sarasota
Legends Bay Market Snapshot | March 2026
As of March 4, 2026, there are 14 active listings in Legends Bay ranging from $700,000 to $6,875,300. The median list price is $1,224,000 with an average price per square foot of $483. The range reflects the full spectrum of the community — from well-priced resale homes to brand-new custom construction topping $6.8M.
Eight homes have closed recently with a median sale price of $1,162,500. Sellers received a median of 94.2 cents on the dollar. The most active price range is $725,000–$1,525,000 where all eight closed sales occurred. Well-priced homes moved in as few as 30 days. Overpriced listings sat for up to 318 days before closing or expiring.
Legends Bay — Common Questions
What are homes selling for in Legends Bay right now?
Based on 8 recent closed sales, the median sale price in Legends Bay is $1,162,500. The average sale price is $1,141,875. Homes have sold from $725,000 to $1,525,000 in recent months.
What is the price per square foot in Legends Bay?
Recent closed sales averaged $389 per square foot. Active listings are currently priced at an average of $483 per square foot, with brand-new 2026 construction commanding the highest rates above $900 per square foot.
How long does it take to sell a home in Legends Bay?
Recent closed sales averaged 176 days on market overall, but well-priced homes moved significantly faster — one closed in just 30 days. Overpriced listings accounted for the longer averages.
Are Legends Bay homes selling at asking price?
The median sale-to-list ratio is 94.2%. The best-priced homes achieved as high as 96.8% of list price. Pricing correctly from day one is the single biggest factor in how fast and how close to asking a home sells.
How many homes are for sale in Legends Bay?
As of March 4, 2026, there are 14 active listings in Legends Bay priced from $700,000 to $6,875,300.
Is Legends Bay a buyer's market or seller's market?
With 14 active listings and no pending contracts in the data, buyers have options across all price points. The sub-$1.5M range has been the most active and will continue to move for sellers who price correctly. Above $3M, inventory is light but buyers have significant leverage given days on market.
Legends Bay Market Snapshot
Legends Bay Bradenton — Updated September 2, 2026 | Source: Stellar MLS
Average List Price
$2.0M
Median list price $1.4M
Avg Price Per SqFt
$531
Median $447/sqft
Avg Sale Price
$1.9M
6 sold · 96.8% sale-to-list
Register below to receive your complimentary market report
Q1 2026 Waterfront Market Highlights
- 0114 active listings span $810K to $6.9M, giving buyers genuine optionality across resale, golf-course, and new-construction inventory.
- 02Average list price of $2.0M against a median of $1.3M signals a small group of high-end custom builds pulling the top end higher.
- 03Price per square foot averages $502 (median $431), making Legends Bay one of the strongest value plays for newer waterfront-adjacent product near Sarasota Bay.
- 047 closed sales averaged $1.2M at 93.2% sale-to-list — accurately priced homes are still moving close to ask through Q1 2026.
Access the "Private" Market
The best waterfront homes often never hit the MLS. Join my private client list for exclusive off-market notifications.